Altova Mailing List Archives
>comp.text.xml Archive Home
>Thread Prev - RFC: thoughts for a "streamlined" XML syntax variant...
>Thread Next - Re: RFC: thoughts for a "streamlined" XML syntax variant...
Re: RFC: thoughts for a "streamlined" XML syntax variant...
Date: 5/11/2012 6:08:00 PM
There have been multiple suggestions for terser syntax, over the years since XML was released to the world. In general, they have failed contact with the real world -- they're harder to work with, and/or they aren't actually significantly more compact (especially when you remember that XML compresses wonderfully), and/or what you'd really want is a custom representation within your application (perhaps straight data structures) and XML only as the export/import interface to the rest of the world. The W3C has looked at a number of "binary XML" representations. I believe there was a working group that was investigating trying to come up with something official. I'm not sure what its status is now; the idea still strikes me as an awkward compromise that is going to face too many conflicting goals. Finally: XML's greatest value is that there are lots of tools already in place that support it. This won't be true of any new syntax. Sorry, but I think there really isn't sufficient value here to make the idea worth pursuing.