Altova Mailing List Archives
>comp.text.xml Archive Home
>Thread Prev - W3C's "Binary XML" - dropped?
>Thread Next - Re: W3C's "Binary XML" - dropped?
Re: W3C's "Binary XML" - dropped?
Date: 12/20/2007 7:55:00 PM
On Dec 20, 6:48 pm, Ivan_G_S <linuxad...@yandex.ru> wrote: > What is the current state of this project? Was it dropped? Dropped. XML's strengths are interoperability and toolability. A binary format would break both, for negligable gains -- a good XML parser can read XML at nearly the same speed that one could deserialize from a binary representation. If you're worried about verbosity XML compresses wonderfully when put through any of the standard adaptive algorithms (zip and its cousins), and decompressing those doesn't add much overhead. While there are certainly things a binary format would be better for, that tends to be a huge mixed bag of goals, many of which directly conflict in the requirements they would want to impose on the data format. If you want a binary format, by all means invent one that suits your needs, and import/export it to XML. But don't expect it to be interoperable. Remember, the whole reason XML took off was that binary formats WEREN'T easily interoperable, even those explicitly intended to be so.